1. It would be extraordinarily easy to bot it and just silence anyone you want.
  2. I agree, moderation is absolutely necessary to maintaine civil discussion, but silencing people, because they have unpopular opinions, is a really bad idea.
  3. I love lemmy because it is the ultimate embodiment of decentralised free speech. This destroys that.
  4. If I were a bad actor, hypothetically, let’s just say lammy.ml or haxbear and I decided I wanted to silence anyone who disagrees with what I have to say. Then I could just make a fork of this project to only value my instances votes and censor anyone who doesn’t agree with what my community thinks.
  5. This tool simply acts as a force multiplier for those who want to use censorship as a tool for mass silencing of descent.

Yes, I’ve read the Q&A, But I can simply think of more ways to abuse this bot for bad than it can be used for good.

  • auk@slrpnk.netM
    2·
    3 months ago

    Ahh so the karma farm isnt federating?

    Yes, that’s right. Communities are not federated except to instances that are subscribed to them.

    Also, it only counts things going forward. When you subscribe to a community, you don’t get the votes going back historically. You only get new votes from that point forward.

    If somone from ur instance subscribes to the karma farm community will that then federate it to ur instance and thus allow ur bot to count those votes?

    Yes. I’ve done a version of that now. If you have the bots in the karma farm make all new posts and mutual votes, then I should be able to pick it up now. The posts you made before won’t take effect, because nothing was federating out at the time that you made them.